URBAN DECAYPerversion Waterproof Black Liquid Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof, Sweat-Proof, Transfer-Resistant, Fine-Point Eye Pen, Flexible Brush Tip, Semi-Matte Black, Vegan, Cruelty-free - 0.018 fl oz

With my oily face, most waterproof eyeliner does not really last that long but this one is an exception. A little bit expensive but worth it.

I received this eyeliner as a gift, and purchased a second when it ran out. It lasts a long time. Easy to apply. No bleeding. Accurate application, whether you prefer a thin line or a thicker one. Never runs off, but easy to remove with makeup remover. It did not irritate my eyes.

I have the oiliest lids of any mammal on the planet. This is used after I use setting powder after doing my whole face. This doesn't move, smear or come off all day. Even when I'm at work in a warm hardly ventilated lab, and the end of the day, and my face is almost as shiny as a mirror in some places! I hope they never stop making this!

Hands down best eyeliner

I got my first liquid liner from Sephora a couple years back and I've finally finished that liner. I was overjoyed to find that Amazon sold it.Packaging: 0/5The liner had hairs sticking in different directions. It almost felt like a used product or the pen was slammed in incorrectly.Longevity of liner: 5/5I have oily eyelids because of my heavy epicanthic fold. A lot of eyeliners tend to smudge after an hour or two. This eyeliner is always perfect at the end of the night or after a swim in the lake.Color: 5/5Such a deep bold black! Love how the amount of product comes out with each stroke and the color really stands out.Drying time: 3/5Takes longer to dry than most other eyeliners I have. I try to give it a good 30 seconds before I open my eye.Warning: After a couple trips abroad, I suspect that the pressure destroyed the liner. The side of the tips started mildly leaking droplets of ink.

This is my favorite eyeliner. I love that it is soft when applying, waterproof, and last longer.

Color keyBlue - Urban Decay (UD)Purple - Maybelline Tattooed Liquid InkRed - Maybelline Hyper EasyPros:WaterproofEasy to applyNot difficult to removeCons:Pigment is not as black as othersCost compared to less expensive brandsDries very quicklyFades through the dayI was a little disappointed in the waterproof eyeliner. It is the best with waterproof but will fade through the day and eventually somewhat smear. I did go over the line a couple times to see if it would get any darker.I have included my hand with UD eyeliner compared to two Maybelline Liquid long stay/waterproof eyeliners. For the price of this eyeliner, Maybellines Hyper Easy is more than half the cost, has a little bit more pigment, and lasts all day. Maybellines tattooed lasts most the day and although it says waterproof, it does start to peel but does have the deepest black pigment of the three.If I am going to pay more for this eyeliner compared to others, then I want to see significantly better results.

Finally I can make beautiful , smooth, upper eye lid lines. It lasts all day. Doesn't smear. So easy to use. Good value.